According to The Scotsman: Willie Collum tackles Rangers and Celtic controversies plus Hearts incident that was ‘right on the limit’.
Willie Collum has backed Rangers’ disputed penalty against St Mirren while explaining that VAR would also have stayed out had the referee waved play on. Scotland’s refereeing chief said neither decision would have met the threshold for intervention, The Scotsman reports.
Nick Walsh awarded the penalty after Samuel Ramos challenged James Penrice during Rangers’ 2-0 win. Ryan Naderi converted. Speaking on the SFA’s VAR Review show, Collum acknowledged limited contact but said Walsh had a clear view and accurately described the incident.
“Here, regardless of the onfield decision, when you look at the footage, it is not one that VAR would touch,” Collum said. His explanation puts the emphasis on correcting clear errors rather than having the video official choose between two defensible interpretations.
Collum also identified a missed booking for Penrice’s high challenge on Aberdeen’s Afeez Aremu in the Premier Sports Cup semi-final. He judged it reckless, rather than merely careless as referee Ryan Lee had described it, but said it lacked the force required for red.
He supported Colby Donovan’s yellow against Dundee United and described Hearts player Rogers Mato’s challenge against Motherwell as borderline: VAR would have upheld a red, but could support the yellow awarded. Across those assessments, Collum stressed that height of contact alone did not establish excessive force or brutality.
Read The Scotsman’s report for Collum’s explanations of each incident.