According to The Scotsman: 'Horrendous' Rangers decision sees Scottish official blasted for 'sheer arrogance'.

VAR’s decision to leave Rangers’ opening penalty untouched in their 2-0 win at St Mirren has divided former players and referees, with the dispute centred on whether minimal contact justified the award.

As reported by The Scotsman, referee Nick Walsh penalised Samuel Ramos for a challenge on James Penrice. Ryan Naderi converted after 18 minutes, before Dan Neil added Rangers’ second just after the hour.

Former Rangers defender Alan Hutton argued on the Scottish Football Social Club that the footage warranted intervention. “All contact in the box isn't a penalty kick,” he said, adding that VAR should have overturned Walsh’s decision. His co-host Michael Stewart also criticised the award and accused Walsh of arrogance in his response to Ramos’s complaints.

Former Premier League referee Dermot Gallagher reached the opposite conclusion on Sky Sports’ Ref Watch. He argued that Ramos did not play the ball and that Walsh’s clear view supported leaving the on-field decision intact. Fellow guest Tim Sherwood accepted that the touch was minimal but still considered it a penalty.

The disagreement concerns both the judgement of the contact and whether VAR should overrule a referee who saw the incident clearly. Those assessments produced sharply different verdicts on the same challenge.

Read The Scotsman’s report for the full set of pundit reactions.