Liverpool should have received a penalty for Jurrien Timber’s shirt pull on Alexander Isak during their 1-0 defeat by Arsenal at Anfield, the Premier League’s Key Match Incidents panel has ruled. Sky Sports reports that four of the five panellists judged referee Andy Madley’s decision incorrect, while three believed VAR Stuart Attwell should have recommended a pitchside review.

The incident came in the 21st minute on 1 November, with Arsenal already ahead through Kai Havertz’s eventual winner. Isak tried to meet Bradley Barcola’s cross but was held back by Timber. The Liverpool striker stayed on his feet, and neither official awarded the penalty.

Liverpool manager Andoni Iraola argued afterwards that Isak’s decision to stay upright had counted against him. Speaking to BBC Match of the Day, he said: “Alex was just in front of him. He was going to head in front of the goal, but couldn’t because he grabbed the shirt.” Iraola said he would tell the striker to go down next time.

The panel’s voting shows where the disagreement lay. One member felt the brief hold had not clearly affected Isak’s ability to reach the ball. Two considered the assessment of its impact too subjective to meet the threshold for VAR intervention. The majority nevertheless judged the failure to award a penalty a clear and obvious error. The panel unanimously agreed that Timber’s challenge did not warrant a red card for denying an obvious goalscoring opportunity, BBC Sport reports.

On Sky Sports, Jamie Carragher questioned why Isak needed to exaggerate the contact for officials to act. Arsenal manager Mikel Arteta said he had not watched the incident back and declined to comment when asked by the broadcaster.

The five-person panel reviews key decisions across every Premier League match. According to Sky Sports, it has examined 196 incidents this season, judging 86 per cent of on-field decisions correct, rising to 97 per cent after VAR intervention. This was one of the exceptions: the majority found that both opportunities to award Liverpool a penalty had been missed.

Read Sky Sports’ report for the panel breakdown and match reaction, and BBC Sport’s coverage for Iraola’s comments.