Cristiano Ronaldo has retired from international football after 23 years with Portugal, bringing a record-breaking career to an end following his dispute with head coach Jorge Jesus. The 41-year-old announced his decision on Thursday, leaving with 146 goals in 234 appearances, Euro 2016 glory and two Nations League titles.

“Today the time has come to hand it over to the future,” Ronaldo said of Portugal’s number seven shirt in a social-media video reported by CBS Sports. He described the decision as difficult and thanked supporters who had shared a journey stretching back to August 2003.

The immediate backdrop was considerably less celebratory. According to CBS Sports, Ronaldo left Portugal’s training camp last month after a disagreement with Jesus, then published an open letter apologising to supporters and team-mates without mentioning the manager. The federation imposed a 30-day suspension, but he would have been eligible for the forthcoming matches against Denmark and Wales. Retirement was therefore not a consequence of continued ineligibility.

His departure also closes a long-running debate about his place in the side. Writing in the Guardian, Jonathan Wilson argues that Ronaldo stayed too long, pointing back to the 2022 World Cup, when Gonçalo Ramos replaced him against Switzerland and scored a hat-trick. Wilson’s assessment is that Portugal’s attacking talent increasingly struggled to function around their most famous player. This summer’s World Cup, Ronaldo’s sixth, ended with defeat by Spain in the last 16.

There is a distinction, though, between leaving Portugal and leaving football. José Mourinho, who coached Ronaldo at Real Madrid, stressed that point at a press conference on Friday. “He hasn’t ended his career, those who know him are aware that he still has goals,” he said, as reported by World Soccer Talk.

The same report puts Ronaldo on 985 career goals after a recent hat-trick, with his Al-Nassr contract running until 2027. The pursuit of 1,000 continues, but Portugal must now choose a successor to a player who helped deliver three international trophies and defined a generation.

Read CBS Sports’ retirement report, the Guardian’s assessment and World Soccer Talk’s coverage of Mourinho’s response.