Aston Villa have moved beyond rebutting Jamie Carragher. By announcing plans for legal action over what they call “unacceptable insults”, they have made his comments a matter of club policy.
Two issues need separating. Suggesting Unai Emery should manage Manchester United belongs to football debate, however tiresome Villa supporters find the assumption that their manager should aspire to work elsewhere. Directing profanity at those supporters is another matter.
Villa’s promise not to let anyone “stop our ascension” frames the dispute as resistance to their progress. That may rally supporters, but it also lends a pundit’s words extraordinary weight. Carragher cannot halt Villa’s rise with an opinion. The club’s strongest argument remains the team Emery builds, rather than the managerial vacancy somebody else imagines for him.