Michael Carrick has confirmed that Bruno Fernandes will retain Manchester United’s captaincy, with reports pointing to a return against Chelsea after clear-the-air talks. Dropping him over an interview established a boundary. Bringing him back without removing the armband defines the limit of that punishment.

That distinction matters. A manager can challenge a captain’s conduct without deciding he can no longer lead. Permanently stripping Fernandes of the role would have turned an immediate dispute into a broader judgement on his standing at the club.

The useful test now concerns behaviour, not ceremony. Fernandes needs to lead without reopening the argument; Carrick needs to judge his football without making every selection another referendum on their relationship. United have enough uncertainty without manufacturing a weekly captaincy debate.