Alexia Putellas has won the Ballon d’Or Féminin for a record-equalling third time, returning to the prize after a four-year wait. At 32, the Barcelona and Spain midfielder has added another major distinction to a career that already demanded a place among the sport’s outstanding figures.
The return matters as much as the total. Individual awards tend to flatten careers into annual snapshots: the winner stands at the summit, everyone else supplies the backdrop. A four-year interval tells a more interesting story. Football’s hierarchy can change without permanently closing the route back for a player who once defined it.
Putellas also extends Spain’s dominance of the award. That reflects genuine excellence, but it creates a responsibility to distinguish two questions that often become entangled. Does the winner deserve recognition? And does the process give the full breadth of women’s football adequate consideration? A convincing answer to the first does not settle the second.
The Guardian’s assessment makes precisely that tension worth examining, praising Putellas while questioning a limited shortlist and the neglect of African football. The criticism need not diminish her achievement. It asks whether an award claiming global authority looks widely enough before deciding whom to celebrate.
Visibility and quality overlap, but they are not identical. Players at prominent clubs and leading national teams offer voters more opportunities to watch, compare and remember their performances. An individual prize should work against that imbalance rather than simply reproduce it. The shortlist is where that ambition first becomes measurable, before anyone debates the final order.
None of this requires inventing a rival winner or treating Putellas as the beneficiary of an undeserved honour. Her third victory stands as the night’s central football achievement in the women’s game. The scrutiny belongs alongside the celebration, not in place of it.
Putellas has demonstrated that a great player can return to the top. The organisers now face a different test: ensuring that players beyond the sport’s most visible centres receive a credible opportunity to reach the conversation.